New digital cluster for the E89

[kgie1217]

Originally Posted by DavesZed

I would keep it as 26, 24. I've checked and although there are two tanks, one is for leaded fuel and one for unleaded, tgere us no difference for the 35is

Hey Dave, I know you removed your instrument cluster but what are your thoughts on the best one out for the E89 right now?

[DavesZed]

Originally Posted by kgie1217

Hey Dave, I know you removed your instrument cluster but what are your thoughts on the best one out for the E89 right now?

Well I've only had direct experience with the one I fitted and used (7 months, and about 7000 miles!) that was Acarnavi. There are some on Aliexpress, but my only concern there would be after sales backup, as sellers on that platform tend to be drop-shippers and have no technical knowledge at all, so you're sort of on your own. And as for the ID4MOTION one, well this requires a lit more cutting and work to get it to fit, although it does look a little more integrated with more options.

[kgie1217]

Originally Posted by DavesZed

Well I've only had direct experience with the one I fitted and used (7 months, and about 7000 miles!) that was Acarnavi. There are some on Aliexpress, but my only concern there would be after sales backup, as sellers on that platform tend to be drop-shippers and have no technical knowledge at all, so you're sort of on your own. And as for the ID4MOTION one, well this requires a lit more cutting and work to get it to fit, although it does look a little more integrated with more options.

Thanks for the response. I'm going back and forth whether to do this modification as well as the Android/Apple Carplay screen.

[B21]

Originally Posted by kgie1217

Hey Dave, I know you removed your instrument cluster but what are your thoughts on the best one out for the E89 right now?

https://e89.zpost.com/forums/showthr...ight=Id4motion

[mittu]

Dave raises a valid point about purchasing from Aliexpress.
You might score a cracking deal like me, but factor in it only comes with a 3 month warranty, and you'll be on here looking for future software updates.
I'm ok with with the compromise. Can't have your cake and eat it too!

Having said that, this cluster doesn't even come close to the id4motion.
I'm pretty underwhelmed by the quality of the themes (software is up to date).
Once you see videos of the id4motion, the graphics on this unit feel craptastic.
You notice all the poor design choices and lack of effort as soon as its switched on.
Themes, animation/transitions, attention to detail, layout, features, graphics, menu, smoothness, etc. are miles behind the id4.

I just wish this had 1 or 2 nicely polished themes.
The more you stare at it, the more you notice all the things that are slightly off.
There's no question which is superior... but the ID4 does cost a lot more.

ID4motion themes are top tier, super polished and offer customisation.
The makers of this Chinese unit need to spend some time on design and graphics.
If they cant do a decent job, at least copy the competition or OEM (to a good standard).

If you're looking to spend 400-500, get this one.
But if your budget stretches to 700, without a shadow of doubt buy the id4motion!

[B21]

Originally Posted by mittu

Dave raises a valid point about purchasing from Aliexpress.
You might score a cracking deal like me, but factor in it only comes with a 3 month warranty, and you'll be on here looking for future software updates. I'm ok with with the compromise.
Can't have your cake and eat it too!

Having said that, this cluster doesn't even come close to the id4motion.
I'm pretty underwhelmed by the quality of the themes (software is up to date).
Once you see videos of the id4motion, the graphics on this unit feel craptastic.
You notice all the poor design choices and lack of effort as soon as its switched on.
Themes, animation/transitions, attention to detail, layout, features, graphics, menu, smoothness, etc. are miles behind the id4.

I just wish this had 1 or 2 nicely polished themes.
The more you stare at it, the more you notice all the things that are slightly off.
There's no question which is superior... but the ID4 does cost a lot more.

ID4motion themes are top tier and super polished.
I just hope in the next software update, the makers spend some time on design and graphics.
If they cant do a decent job, at least copy the competition or OEM (to a good standard).

If you're looking to spend less than 500, get this one.
But if you're budget stretches to 700, without a shadow of doubt buy the id4motion!

Well having gone through the pain of the E89 specific issues of the ID4Motion cluster I have to say I’m very very pleased at the look, feel and capability of the unit..it’s IMHO so much classier than the Chinese alternative…there are issues with it but ongoing suport is good and updates come out at a pace..

[mittu]

Thanks for the demo. All their themes seem thoughtfully designed and super well done.
A mix of analogue and digital options.
I like their Hyper Grid and Orbit drift theme.

[B21]

Originally Posted by mittu

Thanks for the demo. All their themes seem thoughtfully designed and super well done.
A mix of analogue and digital options.
I like their Hyper Grid and Orbit drift theme.

They are very nice so,e themes such as Hyper Grid are only available for older BMWs with the bigger screen..pity..I like that one too..maybe one day..

[Rah-Vee]

On the ID4motion does it correctly record the mileage as well as allow you to make service maintenance updates back to the cars ECU?

I purchased the Chinese version just for fun but I also swap between the original sometimes as it only takes 5 mins to do.

[B21]

Originally Posted by Rah-Vee

On the ID4motion does it correctly record the mileage as well as allow you to make service maintenance updates back to the cars ECU?

I purchased the Chinese version just for fun but I also swap between the original sometimes as it only takes 5 mins to do.

Yes and yes

It’s pretty spot on for speed / distance as you enter diameter / width / aspect ratio of wheels into it as part of initial set up..

Clocks losses a minute a day though..

[bryanhoag]

Originally Posted by B21

Well having gone through the pain of the E89 specific issues of the ID4Motion cluster I have to say I’m very very pleased at the look, feel and capability of the unit..it’s IMHO so much classier than the Chinese alternative…there are issues with it but ongoing suport is good and updates come out at a pace..

Are you able to offer a list of the e89 specific issues and how they were resolved?

[B21]

Originally Posted by bryanhoag

Are you able to offer a list of the e89 specific issues and how they were resolved?

Yes I will do..in part because I did several mods at the same time I’m having issues confirming what is causing what issues..I don’t want to dis ID4Motion on things that are not their issue..having said that with hindsight I can help others now..so will do an interim right up soon..

[alski]

Hi all, I’m really interested in fitting one of these (and an MMI) but don’t have much confidence in self-installation. Can anyone recommend or advise anyone that could do it for me or help me. Based in Berkshire so anywhere south midlands / south and into London would work? Many thanks in advance

[DavesZed]

Originally Posted by alski

Hi all, I’m really interested in fitting one of these (and an MMI) but don’t have much confidence in self-installation. Can anyone recommend or advise anyone that could do it for me or help me. Based in Berkshire so anywhere south midlands / south and into London would work? Many thanks in advance

Do you mean the Chinese one (original post) or the European ID4Motion one?
I can fit the Chinese one and the mmi box, but I'm a little further away, Grantham in Lincolnshire. I've done a few of the digital clusters and loads of the mmi boxes as this is what I do as a sideline, as well as cruise control 👍

[bryanhoag]

For those using the ID4Motion cluster. Does it display the actual speed or the default speed (which is like 3MPH over actual)?

This setting can be chosen when you turn on the digital gauge in the stock cluster.

Thanks!

[B21]

Originally Posted by bryanhoag

For those using the ID4Motion cluster. Does it display the actual speed or the default speed (which is like 3MPH over actual)?

This setting can be chosen when you turn on the digital gauge in the stock cluster.

Thanks!

You program it to show the speed you prefer..there’s a menu for tyre diameter / width / profile that calculates speed …the digital display and analogue display show the same value…I’ve set mine so it’s about spot on..